Liquidity Management

Conventional wisdom states that money must generate returns all the time, even when it is idle. Hence the creation of the money market, a place for trading idle money. When there is a trade, there will be a price; and the price of money is the interest rate. What determines the interest rate? Other than the forces of demand and supply; monetary policy, expectation of changes in the base rate, inflation also influences the price of money.

The money market is also a place where mismatches in assets and liabilities are rectified. Banks with excess funds (liabilities > assets) will sell (lend) the idle cash in the money market and banks facing a shortage of funds (assets > liability) will buy (borrow) money from the market.

The money market is therefore crucial to ensure the banking system and the economy works smoothly.

Why then do I say that the money market is an anomaly in Shariah based finance?

Firstly (I’m already sounding like a broken record), my understanding is, Shariah prohibits the trading of money because money is not a commodity; it is merely a tool to facilitate trade. Money is potential capital, useful only when put into productive economic use.

Secondly, money is a ribawi item, one which cannot be exchanged unless it is equal in value and transacted spot. The following hadith is the basis of this ruling.

The Prophet s.a.w. said “gold for gold, silver for silver, wheat for wheat, barley for barley, dates for dates and salt for salt should be exchanged like for like, equal for equal and hand to hand [on the spot]. If the types of the exchanged commodities are different, then sell them as you wish, if they are exchanged on the basis of a hand-to-hand transaction. (Sahih Muslim)

Therefore, the act of lending overnight money at 3.2%, contravenes the above hadith because (1) the exchanged value differs and (2) it is not exchanged on spot basis.

Then Tawarruq came along. Liquidity management in a Shariah compliant manner is now possible via the buying and selling of commodities (which does not leave the warehouse and is reused again and again for subsequent transactions). The route is longer but the objective is met nonetheless, money is exchanged in different amounts at different times, made “permissible” due to the presence of the trade. It sounds like a hilah to me because the whole transaction is undertaken merely to circumvent Shariah ruling on riba. It also does not entail any direct economic activity. The biggest beneficiary is the commodity brokers, getting paid for facilitating a seemingly pointless transaction.

No doubt, there will be times of excess liquidity and it does not make economic sense to keep the potential capital idle without generating any income.

This excess liquidity can be channelled towards financing short term projects or providing short term funding. Trade financing would be a good place to start. Retailers/traders usually buy from suppliers or wholesalers or manufacturers on credit terms. Banks could offer a short term murabahah facility to finance this type of transactions in the form of a 3 day, 1 week, 2 week or 30 day murabahah financing. This would channel the excess liquidity towards funding real economic activity.

Another way to absorb the excess liquidity is by way of a short term lease. A clearing house needs to be set up. The clearing house shall own a pool of tenanted properties. When a bank (or anyone for that matter) has excess liquidity, they will purchase property from the clearing house and the rental will be paid to them. When they need the cash, the property will be sold back to the clearing house at market value. In most cases, the purchase and sale price would be the same as it is quite unlikely for real estate values to fluctuate very much in the span of a few weeks.

Both methods entails actual economic activity and the returns from the investment are generated from actual economic activity.

There is always a Shariah based solution to every financial need. If there isn’t, the financial transaction is probably not in tandem with Shariah in the first place.

Riba

The prohibition of riba is the foremost issue in Islamic banking and finance. The literal definition for riba is “excess”, “increase”, or “growth”.

In Islamic banking and finance context, riba is often equated with interest. It is not inaccurate to equate riba with the interest rate as the term riba has a broader definition.

The following are the definitions of riba given by some scholars;

Abu al Ala al Maududi – a predetermined excess or surplus over and above the loan received by the creditor conditionally in relation to a specific period. Riba contain the following elements:

i) Excess over and above loan capital

ii) Determination of the excess in relation to time

iii) Stipulation of the excess in the loan document

Abu Bakar ibn al Arabi – riba is excess in return of which no reward is paid.

Engku Rabiah Adawiah – an increase or excess which accrues to the owner in exchange or sale of a commodity or by virtue of a loan arrangement, without giving in return equivalent counter value to the other party.

http://hazariba.com/DefinitionRiba.shtml - a forced increase of value in the medium of exchange (money/commodity) that is loaned or swapped.

Socio-economic justice is one of the main objectives of the Islamic faith. The definitions above show that riba guarantees that only one or some of the contracting parties benefits from the transaction at the expense of the other parties. Therefore, Islam prohibits riba to ensure that the principles of just and equity is preserved, enabling all contracting parties to share the benefits equitably.

Types of riba:

Riba al fadl – excess accruing in sale or barter transaction

Riba al nasiah – excess accruing from a loan transaction (similar ribawi items) in relation to time

Prohibition of Riba in Quran:

1st stage – Surah al Rum verse 39 (Makkah) – call to abolish interest bearing loans and give alms instead.

2nd stage – Surah al Nisaa verses 160-1 (Madinah) – riba was also prohibited to the Jews (reminder)

3rd stage – Surah Ali Imran verse 130 (Makkah) – stronger prohibition

4th stage – Surah al Baqarah verses 275-281 (Makkah) – Strict law prohibiting riba, establishes clear distinction between trade and riba and defines riba as any increment (however small, whatever the reason) added to the principal. Instructing to only receive principal and waive repayment if borrower is in hardship. Cites the consequences for indulging in usury.

Hadith on the prohibition of Riba

Sahih Muslim, Book 010, Number 3854:Abu Sa'id al-Khudri (r) reported Allah's Messenger (p) as saying: Gold is to be paid for by gold, silver by silver, wheat by wheat, barley by barley, dates by dates, salt by salt, like by like, payment being made hand to hand. He who made an addition to it, or asked for an addition, in fact dealt in riba. The receiver and the giver are equally guilty.