Sukuk Ijarah, Part I

Ijarah - is a manfaah (usufruct) type of contract whereby a lessor (owner) leases out an asset or equipment to its client at an agreed rental fee and pre-determined lease period upon the aqad (contract). The ownership, rights and obligations as the owner of the leased asset remains in the hands of the lessor for the duration of the lease. Any costs incidental to the usage are the responsibility of the lessee.

A Fixed Asset based Sukuk Ijarah should have the characteristics of a Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT). If I was to structure a Fixed Asset Sukuk based on the Ijarah contract, it would probably have the following characteristics:

Issuer:
An SPV owned by the Trustees on behalf of the Sukukholders

Principal Activities of the Issuer/SPV:
Owner, manager and Lessor of [warehouses/hypermarket/office, commercial, industrial, educational, residential buildings/ships/aeroplanes – thereafter referred to as ASSETS].

Tenure of Investment:
5 years (for example)

Structure Description:
Investors will receive Sukuk Ijarah issued by the SPV as evidence of their investment in the SPV. SPV shall utilise the investment proceeds to acquire ASSETS (as described in [the hypothetical] Appendix A). The legal title of the ASSETS shall be transferred to the SPV and held in trust for the Investors.

The ASSETS shall not engage or be a party to any activities contrary to or forbidden by Shariah.

The ASSETS shall be leased to the market at the appropriate lease rental rates (as verified by the appointed valuer or industry expert) and for a lease period not exceeding 5 years (or any number of years as agreed by the investors).

Any costs incidental to ownership such as taxes and insurance shall be borne by the Lessor.

Any costs incidental to usage, such as utilities expenses, repairs due to wear and tear and content insurance shall be borne by the Lessee.

Lease rental net of (minimal) SPV cost shall be remitted to Sukukholders half yearly (or annually, quarterly, monthly)

SPV shall instigate legal action against lessees who deliberately and fraudulently dishonour the lease agreements. Failure of the lessees to pay rental due to economic reasons does not require immediate legal action. Instead, a solution has to be found to ensure the lessees are able to resume payment of the rental soonest possible.

Investors wishing to exit the investment, at any time, may sell their share of ownership to anyone, at the prevailing market price of the asset. The prevailing market price shall be based solely on the market value of the asset or NAV.

At the end of 5 years, the ASSETS shall be sold to the market at current prices and Investors will receive their share of the sales proceeds according to their share of investment.
The investors may decide to continue with the investment if the so wish and investors wishing to exit the investment may dispose their shares in the manner described above.


Difference from some of the Malaysian Sukuk Ijarah in the market:

• Under this structure, the SPV assumes full legal ownership of the assets, not just the beneficial ownership.
• This structure does not have a purchase undertaking with a predetermined price, the properties are disposed to the market, at market prices.
• Rental is priced at the real market rental rate and not benchmarked against any interbank rate (LIBOR etc) or interest rates.
  

This structure is basically a REIT. It is not a mind-boggling alien structure that should be scorned upon so correct me if I’m wrong, why isn’t there any such Sukuk structure out the in the market?